String or Mechanical-linked Valves?

More
30 Nov 2017 15:47 #1672 by Chris Reid
String or Mechanical-linked Valves? was created by Chris Reid
I'm a training music educator looking at a horn with a detachable bell at a low price point. My choices are the Jupiter 1100D and Jupiter 1110D. The only difference I can find on their website is that the former is mechanically linked and the latter is string-linked. Unfortunately I can't find a reliable dealer that sells both models to compare price points, so I'm going strictly off your recommendations on design.

Thanks much, all!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
30 Dec 2017 03:21 #1686 by Mark Kolnsberg
Replied by Mark Kolnsberg on topic String or Mechanical-linked Valves?
Strings are quieter wo need for lubrication but need to be changed annually when the valves are taken apart for cleaning. Mechanical linages can be noisier even w lubrication but are faster to reinstall after the annual valve clean. Pros and Cons to both.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
14 Mar 2018 18:54 #1703 by Elaine K Braun
Replied by Elaine K Braun on topic String or Mechanical-linked Valves?
I taught at a school that had Jupiter Horns with mechanical links and the screws always seemed to be coming out.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
17 Apr 2018 03:18 #1711 by James Watt
Replied by James Watt on topic String or Mechanical-linked Valves?
Strings are definitely preferred. Over the years I have owned both types of linkaged horns and now play a double Hoyer with strings on the 3 valves, but it has mechanical linkage to the f/bflat valve. I haven't had to change the strings in literally decades ( I use 25# WOVEN fish line), but the mechanical linkage to the one valve is a constant headache for noise.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 0.344 seconds